Mine are transparent red, 2-1/8". They appear to be this part:
http://www.marcospecialties.com/pinball-parts/PG42

I looked around for a long time and never found one, so I added what was in my Gorgar to Titan's pinball kit database a while back, and made a diagram for it.

Gorgar rubber (resized).png

Rebuilt original flippers are still very good. I installed the Cliffy lane guides and it completely eliminated the ball hop, so that's worthwhile if you can't dial it out with stock hardware. Take apart the spinner, really clean and polish the contact points. Gorgar with a weak spinner is pretty disappointing.

I've been on the list for a while, but not in a hurry, because I'm also on the Paragon list and I don't think I could handle two in a year!

Without the lane change feature, it takes more skill to plunge/nudge into the lane you want. It would be too easy to max out the bonus X if you could lane change. If you can do it nearly every time, it no longer matters.

My email is from October 2016, and it was $649 at the time.

Did it work before and this is a new thing? Should be no problem regardless of angle.

Start by checking to see if the shooter tip is contacting the center of the ball. If the shooter rod is misaligned, contacting the ball at the top or bottom will cause problems.

Besides the manual, there would have been a smaller instruction booklet, a registration card, and a whole bunch of pricing/replay inserts in a big sheet.

My Gorgar has amber inserts for D and E, so I guess they were made both ways. I do like that all of the inserts are opaque on the repro, I think that looks better than original.

I made that chart, based on what came in my gorgar. It worked, but a couple changes could make things fit better. The one labeled F in the top right should probably be smaller. I don't believe an official rubber ring chart exists.

I meant, I made the graphic that you already posted.

An easy feed from the kickout can make that the go-to strategy, but you can change the setup to have it hit the sling or something.

If you can alley pass for D+E to spot numbers, that's an option, but it's harder on some machines than others.

It's possible to complete the GAR bank in a single shot, and after 3 completions it scores 5k per target plus 5k for completion. After 4 it lights an outlane special which can be set to points. Lighting the pops for 1k each can pay off if your pops work well.

So there are other options for scoring good points besides that kickout, especially if you set it up for a bad feed.