The responses you'll receive are easy to predict. People will vote Godzilla, hands down. People already voted with their wallets! If two games come out at similar times and one sells for thousands more on the used market, there's your answer.
You could tell people your son Thor died in a house fire, and they'd still tell you to buy Godzilla.
I struggle to get into either of those games, but that's just me.
Side question: You have a TMNT Pro and a No Fear. How do you find shooting their top loops? I could repeatedly nail No Fear all day long, but I'd make the turtles shot about 10% of the time.