(Topic ID: 293976)

GNRCE Playfield issues!

By Skyemont

2 years ago


Topic Heartbeat

Topic Stats

  • 878 posts
  • 203 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 1 year ago by leonml
  • Topic is favorited by 36 Pinsiders

You

Linked Games

No games have been linked to this topic.

    Topic poll

    “GNRCE Playfield issues!”

    • No issues 34 votes
      30%
    • A few issues but I can deal with it 15 votes
      13%
    • I need a new playfield 63 votes
      56%

    (112 votes)

    Topic Gallery

    View topic image gallery

    Screen Shot 2021-06-09 at 11.02.03 PM (resized).png
    2C59A24D-B668-4C9B-B448-6C5C96A57878 (resized).jpeg
    4AB83D14-A6A4-4BCB-B3A9-C62901F8AB57 (resized).png
    24F4EACC-18BD-4C3A-BB1C-4EBECF729A5E.gif
    pasted_image (resized).jpeg
    96AFECF5-8006-4481-83F9-232B10BB796A (resized).jpeg
    F47BB7BD-444A-4776-96B8-3147FC4D52A9 (resized).png
    jjp-logo-compare.jpg
    unnamed.jpg
    93CFD333-34C5-4DB3-ABFC-31CCBCF9E514 (resized).jpeg
    0A71BF84-51CB-4B9D-9E4C-0B45BCDDA9E1.jpeg
    B8A76BBC-CC62-4001-8ABA-C6275F81E85A (resized).jpeg
    breaking_the_chains.gif
    623D839E-033A-43B7-8B55-0085CFD6C12F.gif
    Screenshot_20210530-083357_Chrome (resized).jpg
    20210530_001747 (resized).jpg

    Topic index (key posts)

    6 key posts have been marked in this topic

    Display key post list sorted by: Post date | Keypost summary | User name

    Post #5 HEP identifies the issue immediatly. Posted by High_End_Pins (2 years ago)

    Post #96 Myth about outlawed chemicals Posted by High_End_Pins (2 years ago)

    Post #173 Mirco clearcoat & post tests Posted by High_End_Pins (2 years ago)

    Post #726 HEP comment on the two easy to see direct issues. Posted by High_End_Pins (2 years ago)

    Post #807 Reminder of thread purpose. Posted by Skyemont (2 years ago)


    Topic indices are generated from key posts and maintained by Pinside Editors. For more information, or to become an editor yourself read this post!

    You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider yelobird.
    Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

    -5
    #60 2 years ago
    Quoted from HookedonPinonics:

    You're asking me if the Abess family were broke how would that change the situation? If that is what is being asked then that takes being able to fix the issue a bit harder to do. We can all admit that this playfield quality issue is not some easy cheap thing. I think we can all see how stopping a line and finding a new contractor to do the work is extremely expensive. We can also believe that sending out new playfields is a costly deal as well. This all comes down to money. If you do not have the money then you make do. You tell your customers "sorry but if we fix this issue we will be done so either deal with it or no more JJP". If you truly cared for your customers you would come out and say "we are extremely sorry for all of this. Please work with us as we deal with these unfortunate issues".
    But they are not broke. They have the resources to fix the issue. They haven't fixed it. They have shown no ambition to fix it and they have not communicated at all about the issue. So why is that? I am just trying to open a conversation on this because no one is holding them accountable for this or asking them this. They can do it. They could do a lot of things with the billions they have. I am not anti rich or anti wealthy or whatever posters want to label me (maybe a bit anti on having multiple billions for that is just dumb). I simply came out and said that the Abess family can fix this issue yet they wont do it. If they truly cared about it, it would be fixed. Why on earth are people defending these individuals? They will not replace your playfields! The only solution they have is to buy it back from you and tell you to F&^# off!
    And if the next question is "well what if they only put a certain amount of investment in JJP and its not enough to fix the issue" Then that goes back to my statement that they don't care enough then to invest more money into it to fix it. For me it all goes down to caring enough. If they cared enough they would fix it. That is totally and reasonably fine to only invest a certain amount in a company. There is nothing wrong with that. Doesn't mean they are bad people. I never said they were. I just stated they don't care enough.

    So lost on your Abess crush. Being an investor in a company does not make you a chemical engineer or playfield specialist. I like many have invested in many companies via the stock market yet they don't call on me to repair there product challenges. Sounds like your just looking for someone to blame? You have money must be your fault! This is not a great situation but is also not the investors issue to figure out thats up to the team of JJP.

    -2
    #69 2 years ago
    Quoted from HookedonPinonics:

    Maybe I am mistaken here but are the Abess Father and Son team majority owners in JJP? Did they not pump a bunch a money to become majority owners and to also keep it going? When did I say that just because you have money makes you know how to fix these issues. You pay someone to fix the issues. Or invest the money in other technologies. They are the ones running the show there from what I have heard and understand. It's their decision to not replace playfields. Its their decision to not fire Mirco and get someone else to do it. It's their decision to put money into the business to make a good product. Why is this being spun on me hating them cause they are rich!? I am not asking them to put their lab coats on and figure it out. I am stating that if they cared enough they would dig into the problem and spend their money to get it fixed. They have not! Why can't you understand this? Its the investors/owners job to put the people in place to fix the issues. If they placed the wrong people in those positions it is on them. No biggie. They then use money to hire/entice better people to get the job done.

    Not to sideline your frustration just saying being an Investor is not the same as production manager or part of the design team. I would Guess the investors visit that facility annually at best to review revenue. Highly unlikely they are reviewing the build design or game layouts. Just an opinion.

    #108 2 years ago
    Quoted from High_End_Pins:

    If you have to wait ten months or even ten weeks you are not using the right product for the application.
    For a playfield a product that is installable in 2 weeks is appropriate.
    If it is not then it’s the wrong product.
    Hardening takes place in a short window. Say 4-8 hours. Curing takes place in a longer period. It can be 2-4 months depending on many factors such as hardner,climate,application thickness and even humidity.
    Most manufacturers of these coating materials say wait six months before waxing to insure you don’t seal a surface before full cure but that is because they are factoring in worst case scenarios and potential unknowns to be in the safe side for warranty concerns.
    If a finish is no good that is instant. It might become evident in an hour,a week or six months.
    No amount of cure time past true hardening or waiting through that two week window will change that. If the finish is appropriate for its intended use it will perform properly as intended. If not it just won’t.
    I hate to keep going on and on here .I don’t really care about JJP playfields at all but I know about coatings and playfields in general and there is just so much misinformation when it comes to the subject when it comes to pinball that it can be tough to keep my knowledge on the subject to myself.

    So what your saying is like Ford with Shelby or Roush we should just have JJP and Stern drop ship All of our games to you so you can rework them to HEP magic! Done! How big is your storage area again? lol Love your feedback and respect your contribution always.

    #110 2 years ago
    Quoted from romulusx:

    Does Jack have any say at all in this?Man if I was Eric,Keefer or any of the super talented guys that make these great games like GnR happen I would be so pissed off.Can you imagine putting all the effort into this and now it's being shit on by the fuckers who do the playfields!Somebody (like Jack) needs to come on here and help us straighten this shit out.

    No idea but yeah I can see this being a blow to the design and software team seeing all their hard work tarnished by something out of their control. Must be hard though my guess not much they can do about it other then watch there creation be torn apart and carry a stigma forever.

    #112 2 years ago
    Quoted from High_End_Pins:

    If you have to wait ten months or even ten weeks you are not using the right product for the application.
    For a playfield a product that is installable in 2 weeks is appropriate.
    If it is not then it’s the wrong product.
    Hardening takes place in a short window. Say 4-8 hours. Curing takes place in a longer period. It can be 2-4 months depending on many factors such as hardner,climate,application thickness and even humidity.
    Most manufacturers of these coating materials say wait six months before waxing to insure you don’t seal a surface before full cure but that is because they are factoring in worst case scenarios and potential unknowns to be in the safe side for warranty concerns.
    If a finish is no good that is instant. It might become evident in an hour,a week or six months.
    No amount of cure time past true hardening or waiting through that two week window will change that. If the finish is appropriate for its intended use it will perform properly as intended. If not it just won’t.
    I hate to keep going on and on here .I don’t really care about JJP playfields at all but I know about coatings and playfields in general and there is just so much misinformation when it comes to the subject when it comes to pinball that it can be tough to keep my knowledge on the subject to myself.

    Quoted from Extraballz:

    Thank you for this. I certainly trust your information on this subject. It is what many of us have thought for quite a while now.

    Ok completely serious on this. There is no question there is an issue. Why not pay on contract someone like Chris at HEP, or Brian from HSA, etc to go to the factory and Mirco and have someone skilled in this as a profession review the process?? What would it hurt? If paid in my view their expert input would be Invaluable! Hell I would sincerely contribute a few hundred to JJP to fund that expedition as I would bet a few others would as well to at Least TRY to find a solution.

    #182 2 years ago
    Quoted from Eskaybee:

    Question for the experts (are we all experts here? Haha). When I get my washers, would it be wise to put a small piece of Mylar over the affected area, then the washer, then the post?
    My biggest concern isn’t just concealment, but prevention of it spreading and getting worse.
    [quoted image]

    Tough call on that one. As the issue is already beyond a washer and up against a stainless rail you can only go so big to hide (no fix) the issue. For me, I would try to Carefully flatten that area (iron or otherwise) and apply a mylar ring. Consider it a flexible bandaid.... Hopefully that will retain any further spread but honestly a crap shoot with that damage sorry.

    #186 2 years ago
    Quoted from High_End_Pins:

    Same process I just detailed on a direct off the shelf Mirco IJ. [quoted image][quoted image]
    Tight. [quoted image]
    Results. [quoted image][quoted image]
    Good to know I am not wasting my time reclearing them.

    Would it be possible to slightly replicate the issue by taping (hammer or screwdriver handle) the Side of those posts to replicate the constant side strikes of the ball to rubber and the constant side pull from the slings firing? Shame there isn't an area on that playfield with ink Below the clear to test these theories.

    #202 2 years ago
    Quoted from woody76:

    he also mentions less torque as well, but all this is just a patch. they need to dive in and fix the real issue.

    Yeah tend to agree. With less torque the post has more flex with the slings firing and ball strike which gives further depth to the issue.

    #205 2 years ago
    Quoted from High_End_Pins:

    Yes. All this is prevention and accommodation of the problem.
    The solution is going to come down to a change in process and or chemistry.
    When I reclear them I am changing the chemistry of the top coat. That’s all I can do at this stage.
    I put the washers in there to take the other factors out of the equation and hand assembly the games.
    I haven’t had any problems at all and I have no reservations about building games around these playfields with those provisions but it’s a process.

    Question for Mr #HEP Like your knowledge I also value the input from Peter in Hamburg who also makes great playfields. Some time ago (somewhere in all these threads) he tried to share his opinion on the situation being the preparation of the wood Before ink is applied. He mentioned how critical the sealer coat was to proper ink adhesion. Like playfield touch up do you suspect they are laying down a clear coat base Then applying art Or are they simply applying art then clear coating? Seems that one element is being missed or improperly done (rushed) hence most have no issue when no art is applied.

    #207 2 years ago
    Quoted from JodyG:

    Stern does a clear coat layer, then art, then clear again.

    Hence maybe why they are not having issues?

    #223 2 years ago
    Quoted from Damonator:

    "we know there's a problem for some folks and they will be compensated" would go a long ways to settle down the chatter.

    Sadly as I said before I think it is Highly unlikely for an issue like this that Any company will make or publish a statement like this. Can they and should they fix it, Hell yeah. Do I expect to ever see them admit fault, never. Every conceivable issue ever related to the playfield would at that point become compensated debate. Just don't expect to ever see that happen personally. Again, not saying its right just a managed expectation.

    #321 2 years ago
    Quoted from Skyemont:

    The point is guys I want GNR. Send me a playfield in lieu of 12,500???

    Tough call man sucks. Especially when you like the game and whos kidding who the value is likely Higher then the sell back even with damage covered with washers. Only suggestion would be to grab the return option and while waiting list it for more to see which returns the best result. Or (Crappy resolution!) tell them as you do love the game could they sell a replacement PF at cost or less to retain a client?? Sucky solution but that recourse would absolve future resell lose somewhat.

    #327 2 years ago
    Quoted from BMore-Pinball:

    Everybody is claiming the value is higher than retail, even with the chipping and bubbling playfield
    Just Curious - which one of you who don't already have a CE are willing to buy one with a defective PF for $15 grand .... not me
    I would rather pay more for a defect free one or buy an LE down the line if they can fix this issue with certainty

    Since they all assume to have an issue can you point me to a single FS add that is less then list price? And yes I would still buy one at a premium.

    #448 2 years ago
    Quoted from Supermans:

    JJP needs to implement this simple fix into all of their future playfields and the problem will be solved.

    So you have some proof that fixing this problem at a post that shows up after a few hundred plays will Not effect the Rest of the playfield after say a year or more?? I would like to see that report.

    #450 2 years ago
    Quoted from gliebig:

    Unless they change their processes, a replacement playfield is going to shit the bed also. Not sure why everyone thinks the replacement playfields will be defect free. They'll still be garbage.

    Just imaging how much that would compound your frustration to do ALL of that replacement work and have the same result! Yikes.

    #452 2 years ago
    Quoted from gunstarhero:

    I’m sure the hope is with longer curing time, proper assembly and maybe some slight reworking that you won’t see the same kind of damage being done at the posts.

    Yeah not sure that theory sticks. Many of the first batch of games had issues and those were stalled for close to a year waiting for Covid to pass. Don't think time will fix this. And from the few pics shown may actually be worse. Early ones simply pooled which I can repair. Later ones cured and shattered the CC.

    #486 2 years ago
    Quoted from wrb1977:

    If there is, I will gladly edit my post and the other thread if there is someone else on Pinside more appropriate to handle this. He’s the only Pinsider I know that says Jersey Jack Pinball in his profile.

    Seems like Jacks cell number has been posted a multiple times. Give him a call. While not the current decision maker he has more voice then kicking #LTG.

    #488 2 years ago
    Quoted from JohnTTwo:

    I did call Jack left a message, but never heard back from him.

    Call again. Seems important to you why would you stop at one message?

    #500 2 years ago
    Quoted from Skyemont:

    So he paid for it and got it from who?!

    Post 382 showed that they were willing to sell him a playfield. Sell not give I suspect.

    gfg (resized).jpggfg (resized).jpg
    #502 2 years ago
    Quoted from seenev:

    Didn't they offer half price PotC playfields to people with issues and then later refund the payment when they finally acknowledged the problem?

    True but what they "Did" does not always qualify as what they "Do" now. Seems that run on the bank door was since closed for any inquiry.

    #507 2 years ago
    Quoted from Phbooms:

    Start bombing Slash's facebook, instagram, or anything he might look at with pictures of playfields falling apart demanding he do something for his fans and pinball in general.. He was SOO important during the build and proud of the machine that he should feel ashamed of being part of this debacle at this point. He called Mcartney now he needs to call JJP and tell them to fix the issues or pull his name and all assets off any games moving forward. Bet that would give alittle extra umph to the call to arms over this bullshit if he actually took notice and cares enough to speak up since his name, music, hat, band, face, voice and supposedly some design went into this game.

    Sadly thats actually an aggressive approach that would get someones attention.

    #612 2 years ago
    Quoted from micro:

    I just put in my claim and was asked to send pictures today which I did (these).
    Will the iron method do any good here? It does seem like there is a pool going on that could be flattened. I’d imagine it will help to level that high point out, but I’d imagine the white marks will remain.
    Mylar rings and plastic washers on order, but maybe I’ll need to use another washer to actually cover the wear. I guess I’ll find out in a week or so. [quoted image][quoted image]

    Looking at your pic it does look repairable However as you submitted a claim I would strongly advise waiting to hear what they say if anything. Just an opinion.

    1 week later
    #864 2 years ago
    Quoted from TigerLaw:

    Has Mirco made any statement that they view the playfield quality as acceptable or touted their “quality products”?

    Not sure when it happed but if you look at the Mirco site any and All written dialog pertaining to warranty, conditions, or quality are removed. Its just a default setup page. lol Seems like they have screened themselves from customers and OEM partners?

    Screen Shot 2021-06-09 at 11.02.03 PM (resized).pngScreen Shot 2021-06-09 at 11.02.03 PM (resized).png

    You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider yelobird.
    Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

    Reply

    Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.

    Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

    Donate to Pinside

    Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!


    This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/gnrce-playfield-issues?tu=yelobird and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.

    Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.