Have both. POTC easily wins on playfield design, flow, “toys” that interact with the ball, and code depth/strategy. But GNR is the far more exciting game - lights, sounds, visuals… Disney World vs. a concert - Eric/JJP did an amazing job on both creating the intended world-under-glass. So take your pick. I’d probably keep POTC since it will have a lasting place in pinball history IMO (modern TZ).