I have a POTC CE and I’ve played GNR Standard edition last week. I have to say if you like music then the GNR is really an awsome game but the music theme is something that has to be your thing . While the POTC is a machine for everyone and also is a machine that has so much to look for that after playing it for hours it still shows me stuff I’ve never seen before ... so POTC for me ... savvy?!