I've never played one, but the game looks great and the theme is one everone knows and most people like. I probably would have bought one if it had come up back in the '90s when I was looking for games (before I ran out of space). Also might have bought The Shadow, Getaway, or Funhouse back then. But I know I like the pins in my game room more, because I had the word out to my distributors that I wanted them and I actively looked for them, which I did not do for those other games. It's all in personal taste, since WHOdunnit is a must-have to me while the great MM is not.