I love them both, I played TH in it's very early stages and loved it back then. I watched GB. I like the theme and it works good for everyone since it is a well known movie. I'm awaiting my hobbit and hope in the future I will have a GB. I am not a stern fan, but I think this time they got it right. However to choose between one or the other is just premature at this time. I think TH needs an updated code and as for GB, aside from knowing the movie, we have not much to go on. It looks good but I haven't played it to get a real opinion. Great theme but is the code up to date? Are there any bugs in the system? just like TH there are a lot of unknowns. They are both entirely two different games to compare and It's just way to early to judge.