i realise i never posted the final solution to this issue (which is now troubling another pinsider). In case it helps anyone else in the future, the solution ended up being a new set of trough boards in combination with a new node board. I'm not sure if some of the replacement parts i was sent along the way were coincidentally also faulty, but i ended up with multiple trough boards and multiple node boards and after trying different combinations of the replacement parts it eventually started working again....
Just an additional piece of info, before getting everything working, there was an sequence of events that seemed like a clue (not sure if it was actually that helpful in the end), but i'll post it in case it helps someone else work out whats happening
- i put a new node board in and it solved the lighting problem i was having
- then i went through and tested all the coils (via the menu)
- at the end of that the lighting problem was back
- power cycling didn't fix it, but putting in another node board in did
This made me think that one of the coils was shorting the node board. In the end, as per the above, i just seemed to get lucky with the right combination of node boards and trough boards for everything to work, but i still wonder if part of the reason it took so long to solve (and that in the end the working solution seemed like something i had already tried was that some cable was lose or not connected to the node board properly so that a coil firing would short each new node board that i tried.