Just moved to Florida and having a new house built. $25000 upgrade for a barreled/tiled or metal roof. Is it worth the price? I say yes. I'm leaning towards metal. My new neighbors house was built in 2008 and his asphalt shingles need to be replaced. He got 3 quotes which averaged $16000. Asphalt shingles life span 18 to 25 years maybe less in the Florida sun. What will a asphalt shingle roof cost 20 years from now? Just look how much pinball machines have increased over 20 years. CraZy..ha ha I will leave that for the other thread.