ASLE is a lot of fun - that would be my pick of the 3.
A lot of pinsiders were against the game before it even came out, as they don't like the band. The dislike of the band (or half of the bands career) keeps a lot of opinions negative on the title. But if you don't have that issue (IE: like the band and songs in the game), it's a great shooter with fun modes for sure!
The 2X playfield feature using the upper playfield is great and the code update has balanced out the difficulty / rewards of the various modes.