For me ASLE.

As much as I love GB and Star Trek, I would pick ASLE. Great underrated game.

They’re all good pins. Really boils down to what theme/layout you like best. I personally like Star Trek the best of those three, in enjoy the fast games, 3 Flippers and 3 Ramps

GB: fun game but not a fan of the designer and linear ruleset.

ST: fascinating gameplay. Immersive sound package. Warp ramp = best ramp in pinball, so fun. Awesome light package. Biggest flaw of the game is the tough as nails shot(s) to start a mission and you pretty much need to have a mission going at all times and there’s 18 of them making that shot even more of a negative, it really kills the flow of the game. But besides that, the game is fun as hell.

AS: besides one or two songs, the music really isn’t good for pinball (and I’m an Aerosmith fan). Jacky call outs are ear wrenching. Modes are generic and not too exciting. The game thrives on building toys multiball (6-ball) and the 2 wizard modes. Otherwise, the game doesn’t have much to do and gets stale quick.

All in all. My pick is ST. Lots of excitement, speed, and adrenaline. Awesome sound package. A bit rough trying to get to enterprise amok or 5 year mission, but rest is cool.

I sold my ST solely based on that start a mission shot.

Does it have to be one of those three? Because I'd pass on all of them. GB is a polarizing, flawed game. Only get it if you've played it a lot and really love it. Aerosmith is eh, there are better Sterns, get Metallica if you want a rock pin. Star Trek is fun, probably the best of the three, but I personally got tired of it quickly and sold it, it feels very samey after a while.

IMO TWD pro and MET pro and Acdc premium are better but of that list I’d get ST (however I prefer SM with a similar layout).

IMO AFM remake is one of the best pins around but I do love TWD and Met (both pro) if you have considered either one both are excellent.

Of those 3 my vote would be Aerosmith....I hated ST so I sold it....played several frustrating games on GB so thats a BIG NO.....IMO AC/DC or MET are better rock pins than Aerosmith...

Either star trek or Aerosmith I think I will give the edge to Aerosmith though.

Aerosmith LE. Great game. Fun game for pinheads and friends and fmaily as well.

Word. Of the three Aerosmith LE is the one I come closest to recommending, but honestly all three are not super-great. GB might get better with the new code coming at The Rapture, but it's not recommendable at present.

I'd pick 3 different contenders.

If you’re a beginner and would like a fairly easy to understand game = AFM remake (or Spiderman) or Iron Man.

If you like complex brutal game rules that require more thought to get the most out (imo) TWD pro TWD pro is the way to go (imo). I prefer pro but some prefer the premium.

ACDC, MET, MBR. Same great coder but three different designers and styles of play.

Need more information to make a proper recommendation. Will this be your only pin? If not, what else do you have? Do you know if you're a flow or a stop'n'go player?

Same. Love GB at first but the more I played it the more I hated it. Definitely get a lot of plays before deciding to buy one. I don't like Aerosmith either but to be fair I have not played it that much. I owned a ST pro for a while but sold it. Enjoyed it but don't miss it. Better to find a used one cheap. Metallica is the best Stern imo. Gameplay is fantastic thanks to Lyman. Iron Maiden is also a ton of fun. If it had a different theme I would be all over it.

I would put Walking Dead over Metallica. I'm not turned on by the zombie gore, but you have to admit the game's a masterpiece.

I would go with a GB Prem ........ eventually it will be a great game when code drops. By far the most toys of the three.

If you go ST, get a pro as there is almost zero gameplay difference. If you interested in going that route I may be putting up my ST pro that has ALL the best mods and is loaded up. I bought game NIB. Its as new. Shoot me a PM if interested.

I would hold out for another GOT pro if I were you. Out of box can be just as good as NIB if from the right home. As for the three you are choosing from, ST is the better one. Modes are too vanilla and need code to give them pourpose. I actually like the mode shot start, helps break the game up and is an accomplishment when you hit it.

I’ve got a fully modded Ghostbusters LE in the marketplace if you’re interested pm me.

ST would get my vote. The game flows so smooth. The sounds and dots are great. The warp ramp is the best. Great lightshow and the ship is a great toy that does multiple things.

With better code GB could be a lot better. AS just didn't come together for me. Nice layout and features, but I just don't like the code or the songs they picked for the game.

I own ST, but to me it's still a buggy unfinished game. GB is far worse in this regard. Common factor? Dwight is code lead.

I'd go for Aerosmith if I had to choose one of the three, which is a very solid game now after Lonnie's last update. Even if IMO it's a waste to not just go for the Pro.

But on the other hand, ST is SAM rather than Spike which is a significant factor for some, including me. So if I was in the market right now, I wouldn't choose any of them, until such time as Spike schematics are fully released, documented, and either Stern vastly reduce the price of boards, or a third party starts producing them.

GoT is another Dwight game that needs to be finished. Some horrendous bugs and score imbalances.

If you buy an AS LE I would get a HUO one if I were you. NIB would take a huge hit on reseale once you own it. HUO would be $7000-$7500 with some toys.

May want to say where you are located. You don’t have to be specific. Folks may have some games for sale in your area.

I've never been a big fan of people hiding their location and collection on their pinside profile. Makes it harder when you ask for advice.

Of all the games I’ve sold, I miss Spider-Man the most. It’s pure fun, flow with enough strategy to keep it interesting and not be too simple. I really want a Walking Dead again too. It’s a masterpiece, but will also frustrate the hell out of you.

ASLE is a lot of fun - that would be my pick of the 3.
A lot of pinsiders were against the game before it even came out, as they don't like the band. The dislike of the band (or half of the bands career) keeps a lot of opinions negative on the title. But if you don't have that issue (IE: like the band and songs in the game), it's a great shooter with fun modes for sure!

The 2X playfield feature using the upper playfield is great and the code update has balanced out the difficulty / rewards of the various modes.

TNA is fantastic simple rules, it's great light and sound and very adrenaline rush plays veery different than my other 11 pins.

For something nice DI or Woz both of which feel different than our Stern pins. I know they cost money but they both are so well built and have a lot of features (magnets, toys etc.) and great light shows.

Of the ones you listed I would get ST. If I were getting a new stern I would get SW. If you are looking for JJP, and you did not like Hobbit, I would give POTC a try.

All three are really good. I know I’m in the minority, but GB is one of my favorite pins.

I bought my LE from the beginning, and haven’t had any issues, other than adding plastic protectors.

Great theme, audio and really fun to play. Hopefully we get a code soon, that will hopefully fix the inconsistent scoring.

Star Trek Premium

I wouldn't call that NOB. I'd call it USED.

2200 does not fit any definition of "new" no matter what words you put after it. NOB is an absolutely ridiculous designation and I do not know why it exists. That's a decent amount of plays, but wouldn't be a deal breaker IF the price reflects the fact that it is well used. There is no way that it got 2200 plays at one show. That is more like 5 shows worth if I were guessing. My gut tells me your distributer is lying to you and it was either routed or had a couple owners before finding its way to his "inventory". Be cautious with this guy...between this and the one he "tipped over" (more like sold to someone else for more $), my spidey-senses would be tingling.

All that said...if GoT is the game you decided on, that is the one you should get. It's a fantastic game. Of the others you mentioned, ST is by far my favorite, however it didn't sound like you were in love with any of them. It really boils down to what you want to own...do not just buy what happens to be available. Figure out what you really want, and you will eventually find one.

Personally, if a used stern premium isn't 700 to 1000 less than new I don't even bother with it. To me, used is used and pricing should reflect that. Star Trek is an awesome game, maybe my favorite stern.