I can't even begin to discuss the amount of misinformation in this thread.
...but I'll start with this. Potential energy in a gallon of X doesn't translate via 1to1 math into mechanical work. It depends on so much more related to the design of the engine. What's not converted is lost as heat, and sometimes just pushed through the engine into the exhaust system.
All grades of fuel are comingled by their respective grade. Rbob, cbob, 87 clear, etc... They all come up the pipeline and dumped into their respective tanks where the owners maintain an allocation/inventory. Various additives are added at time of loading at the rack per the sales contract.
Anyway, the OP found his solution, and it's not uncommon that during the seasonal change over this occurs. Modern vehicles don't just respond instantly to the reid vapor pressure changes...