I guess you are the Captain of the Infamous Price Police. If you want his machine, make him an offer, its that simple. That's how the real world works. As FREDDY would say, "What are you waitin for?" Currently your actions read as something like, "I want this to steal this guy's machine for a bottom of the barrel price and want to beat him up and make him feel bad about trying to get a good price for his machine." Oh wait, I just joined Pinside so I guess anything that I say isn't credible either!
OP, FREDDY's a fun game, you should have no problem getting 2500 if it is in good shape! Good luck with the sale!
Did you really join pinside yesterday just to comment on this thread and put a ridiculous price tag on this game?
I purchased FREDDY several months ago in excellent condition no pf wear, cab excellent, working 100% but had to replace the claw, all for $1100.00. This game was ok at best it's one of Gottliebs better machines, the call outs were funny but too redundant, the boiler room shot is fun, FREDDY spitting balls was cool, the claw flipper was no biggie and the flow was ok but with no ramps to shoot for it did get old quickly. I'm a diehard horror fan but FREDDY didn't have the staying power for me IMHO. If your going to buy a 2k game then go for a BSD, TS, FT, T2 or something else thats offers more for your buck.