I seriously can't tell if you are joking or sincere especially since it's you.

If joking - Pretty funny.

If sincere - Then yeah, I think you were not being reasonable. $1K and asking someone to deliver is not a fair offer in my opinion. Even if the game is only worth $800 or so their is no way in the world I would spend half a day delivering a pinball machine for less than I really wanted to someone who hasn't exactly been friendly to me. If the Op would have kept a calmer head I do think he could have got $1K for this machine. If he was local I would have been interested at that price as everything looks OK except the PF.

If you would have started off with your offer at the start then I would feel otherwise.