I hate to be the guy to tell you that you don't get to dictate lifetime prices for pins. You don't have to like the price - only the person buying the game will decide that. Like it or not, prices are going up and will continue to go up on both new and used pins. I sold a nice Getaway that wasn't quite as nice as this one and without all the mods for $2900 a year or so ago. Pretty sure I could of got more for it and prices have gone up since then. Seller's price may be a bit ambitious but not too far off what I would list if it was my game.

$2500 for a nice Getaway is a pretty good deal imo. Could be a variety of reasons it has not sold - location, seller communication, condition issues not reported, etc. This one has some added value in mods but that may not be worth much to some people. Market will sort it out.