Quoted from Mizzou0103:
Someone sold one for $4500 with screw holes in the playfield and broken plastics.
I remember that one. Two screw holes in the playfield would be less damage then the wear on your playfield. New plastics are what? About $150.
There was also one on Fb in really great condition a few months ago for $4300. I passed on it to buy my Scared Stiff.
Not trying to bash your price since I think it's a pretty average price for the condition game is in. But the real question is what is the right price for the game to sell??