I actually have a replacement here. Too dark for my taste's though. The original to me looks much better even with some minor flaws.

That's how the game works! Balls hold over from game to game.

I don't have a wish list because it would be too long. People just need to throw at me what they have. Something in the 2500 range? give or take 500. idk.

NO! I only have a few plays on it, I love it. & more importantly it's the only game I have that my GF likes. That matters! She doesn't appreciate the depth & rarity on catacomb like we all do here!
Such depth in rules for a game this age, I had no idea I had to watch a video on the rules to catch some of the finer details. It's a cerebral game.