I’m going to say not quite, because I’m going to put mine on the market for 4K soon. Great game, but 7 years is enough BSD games played to hit that “meh” feeling.

If I’m selling it, it is an A title in collector quality shape.
If I don’t care about the game, it’s a B title.
If I’m buying it, it’s a C title in “players” condition and you’re gonna need to knock off some money for me to even put that load in my car.

There is no real definition of these classifications. Generally, well regarded games are A titles. Like MM, or AFM, or LOTR. The top tier games. B titles are normally great games, but have some flaws. For instance, Getaway. A freaking awesome game that’s a bit shallow (I’m allowed to say that because I own one and love the game). A C title is something generic that some people really like, but it just can’t get anywhere near the top titles. A good example of a C game is Roller Coaster Tycoon. It’s Pedestrian, but still quite a bit of fun if you like that kind of fun. And finally, you have the D titles that would work better as firewood, like Judge Dredd (the only title I sold after 2 weeks, because it sucked so bad).