Not sure why the pinside marker for new member isn't showing up since it looks like a new member as of today.

Yes, the picture is of a Hot Shot which is the 4 Player version of a Big Shot. May be an honest mistake but a bit of a red flag. Other for sale item is being sold as "fully Restored" in the description (not just the pinside selector) and is very obviously not restored. Another red flag. Just do your due diligence. May be someone new to pinball and honest mistakes or could be another one of the many scammer adds that are popping up now.