Quoted from shacklersrevenge:I could have bought this game for two dollars, so I should list it for two dollars?
Two dollars?!?!? I'll buy that for a dollar!
(Ok, that wasn't as funny as I hoped it would look ... an epic fail at humor so bad that I had to post it)
Sell the game for whatever you want. To hell with what people say. I, personally, hope you found it in a pile for free and are getting a nice profit. I've seen you sell lots of stuff on Pinside for very reasonable prices ! People are always going to complain about prices. Even when pins were cheap, people would bitch about prices incessantly.
If you want to have some fun, "reduce" the price from $4100 to $4300 .