Had the same think happen on our ST-LE upper Right Flipper, - took everything apart, everything looked fine put it back together and worked normally for about 20-25 Games & it started again.
Next I changed out the PF Bushing, Plunger, Coil Stop, the Coils Nylon Sleeve & made sure there was some up/down play on the Flipper Shaft.
Worked fine for about 300 Games & is now its doing it again (intermittently but still identical to the original issue).
Next I'm going to try changing out the Flipper itself.
I have friends with ST that have had this issue intermittently (upper right Flipper sticking) so maybe it seems to be a possible ST trait ?
Our Game only has about 1800 plays TOTAL on it so the Plunger & Coil Stops should be fine IMO.
Kim