Two and a half weeks ago, one of my plastic flippers broke, so I decided to upgrade to Precision Pinball's CNC flippers. I purchased his kit that includes the bushings, which makes the flipper mechanism have zero slop by incorporating the close tolerance metal bushings with their Oilite® impregnated sleeves. Here is the link to the kit if you are interested after reading my review and experience. If you do order them, make sure you contact him first because the lightning flipper size isn't an option on the site.
https://precisionpinballproducts.com/shop/ols/products/precision-flip-two-flipper-kits-for-stern-games-prc-flp-two-flp1
I installed the new flippers and have been using them for one and a half weeks now. John's flippers were super easy to install and adjust. Currently, he only has silver ones available in the Lightning Flipper size, and I was worried that they might not look great on my Fish Tales machine. Surprisingly, the silver flippers turned out better than I expected.
The only issue I experienced initially was the ball bouncing from the guide to the flipper. I wasn't sure if the round/fat part of John's flippers was thicker than the original Lightnings. After adjusting the flipper angle several times, I posted about my bounce problem in the following Pinside post of reviews of the flippers:
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/review-precision-pinball-products-cnc-flipper-system/page/46#post-7514688
John confirmed that his flippers were indeed a bit thicker, which could cause the bounce issue. At this point, both John and other Pinside community members suggested adjusting the ball guides to fix the issue. Initially, I didn't think you could adjust them, which is why I didn't try this (long time pinball fan but new to ownership and maintenance), but after giving it a try, I was able to make the necessary adjustments, which solved my problem.
I've included the actual URLs to the videos of the new flippers and the old flippers below. The new flipper video is before the adjustment and shows the bounce issue I experienced.
Original flippers video: https://photos.app.goo.gl/impgVXZgQq35E4JL7
New flipper video right after installation: https://photos.app.goo.gl/L3ZAvnayayS26T9K8
New flippers video (before adjustment): https://photos.app.goo.gl/roAKZDkx4bPyTdVF9
Overall, I'm extremely satisfied with this upgrade after making the necessary adjustments. If anyone has also done this upgrade, I'd love to hear your review and experience.
PXL_20230403_235536935 (resized).jpgPXL_20230403_235528846 (resized).jpgPXL_20230403_235548983 (resized).jpgScreenshot 2023-04-12 11.50.27 AM (resized).pngScreenshot 2023-04-12 11.49.58 AM (resized).pngPXL_20230325_042745344 (resized).jpg