There are lots of good ones these days, and the top 100 is a great place to find in-depth reviews and videos.
I really think you would be happiest with a very good condition twilight zone. You know you like it already, it checks your boxes, and you have a lot of nostalgia tied to it.
Jurassic park, Iron maiden, avengers infinity quest, and Teenage mutant ninja turtles all check off many of your boxes as well.
You may also give consideration to a jersey jack game or even Spooky's alice Cooper.