Quoted from zermeno68:1. Replayability.
2. Rule set comparison. I am not fully aware how deep both go.
3. Shot satisfaction.
4. overall enjoyment for intermediate players.
5. Lastly, which pin would you keep for Home use? Star Wars (Premium/LE) or Metallica (Premium/LE)?
1. Both are great in this category
2. Star Wars has more to do in general. I use all the characters, none of them are horrribly unbalanced.
Metallica isn’t a mode based game, it has modes but they are all more like mini wizard modes.
3. Both have good shot moments. The general shot feel is the same.
4. You’ll like them both as an intermediate player.
5. I sold Metallica because I played thousands of games on it. It is a great game, just burned out on it.
I got with the idea of selling Star Wars, but I have kept that one so far.