All great games and tough choices.
I voted MM because I like the theme and gameplay a little more than AFM.
Went with LOTR over JP2 but they are both great. Guests really enjoy playing LOTR as most seem to "luck" into one of the multiballs and the voice acting really draws them in. JP2 is a solid shooter with many fun shots, Keith designed a great machine.
My personal overall #1 got knocked out last round (JJP POTC) but I recognize it isn't everyone's cup of tea.