Quoted from John_I:
I'm guessing the writing is so bad in this version because they don't have comic books to roughly follow?
I hate to get into it, and I hope I don't offend anybody, but this is my take on it.
Most of the time when I see actors/actresses/writers/producers for this show, for instance on "Talking Dead", they always amaze me in that many of them don't seem to get what's appealing about the show. Chris Hardwick does seem to get it, but the others always act like they're trying to tell this deep tale about humanity and what goes on in people's souls or something. They speak as if they think that we like the morality of the show, or the struggle that Michonne is going through in her heart.
The way I've always appreciated the show is that it's kind of campy, the whole premise is ridiculous but it's kind of fun because they get to mindlessly destroy things. What happens when they go into a deserted drug store? What happens if they take over a prison, and there's still people locked up!!!! What happens if they go to the CDC? What happens if they're in a department store in downtown Atlanta??? What if somebody gets handcuffed to the roof???!!!! What if you had a tank!!??? All this stuff was bad-ass and awesome! Couldn't wait to see the next episode.
------------------------------------------------------------------
So when the writers get it in their head to tell a story about the hearts of the characters, they drive it off into the ditch. The comic books from the first show keep it at least somewhat grounded in the original premise.
The only reason we care about Carol's character is because there was so much action and cool shit going on in the original season, that everybody got attached to her and now they really like her. We never would have cared about her if she didn't beat her rapist, asshole husband's head in with a pick axe in that one episode! That is what this show is about!
You can't do a whole season trying to force people to like characters just because they deliver soliloquies and seem like victims.... or at least you can't in a show that's all about blood, guts, and zombies eating your throat.