For me its not even close. I bought both NIB. Family Guy is gone and TSPPP is bolted to the floor. The crude humor in FG at first was pretty funny but after a very short while it got damn near embarrassing. From strictly a pinball standpoint it's not even close. The TSPPP layout, art and deep rule set never get old for me. As for FG, I grew to hate Stewie Pinball so much I honestly tried to avoid hitting the scoop to qualify it while playing. I don't miss FG for a second.