Simpsons is a MUCH better game. Family guy is funny but the playfield stinks. One ramp, hidden pop bumpers. A mini playfield that gets boring after 3 plays (physics are nothing like a real table. More like a cheap childrens pinball you get at radio shack). Probably Lawlor's worst design.

Simpsons is DEEP, tons of shots. Upper playfield is small but actually challenging. Stackable multiballs and modes, bunch of wizard modes. Springfield mystery spot. It's really no contest IMO.

I don't think it's even fair to compare the 2. TSPP vs LOTR would be a closer debate. FGY is closer to games like BBH.

It's really no contest IMO. It's like comparing a thoroughbred to a donkey. Sure, the donkey looks hilarious and makes funny noises.. but at the end of the day the race horse is tops.