The picture below shows the 5Vs I'm getting. The game isn't resetting. But while my DMM reads around 4.86 V, the scope shows a close to 700 mV swing. I scoped out a couple other WPC machines and their 5V on the scope has a significantly smaller swing.
So I'm planning on getting a new LM323 (NTE931) and trying it out... unless someone says I'm going down the wrong path.
Thanks