100% this. I've got finite space in my game room (and even fewer funds). If I'm dropping $5K+ on a game, the theme has to appeal to me (hence why 7/8ths of collection is horror-related... and the other is Tron).

That's why I'm really torn on my next pin. It's either going to be Elvira 3 or Star Wars, depending on pics/details. Alice Cooper is the dark horse (the playfield art would have to be a big leap from RZ's in order for me to bite).

I also own a 2006 GT (black with silver stripes). I've also got a restored '65 Convertible in the garage (red on red), and my first car was a '66 coupe (powder blue). That said, Mustang, oddly enough, had absolutely ZERO appeal to me as a theme, which just goes to show that theme is both important and highly subjective.