Quoted from ArcadeTechNerd:Well... I suppose it depends in part on if you really want some of the optional video modes that the LCD version offers.
When I was trying to make up my mind on the LED/LCD issue I was struggling until I got to see a couple of machines next to each other, one with LED one with LCD. Decision made! The LED unit just "felt" right. Something about the physical pixel appearance vs. the LCD drawing them in. And I suppose it could be more than a little dependent on the particular machine. Doctor Who has more of a "classic" vibe to it, so going with a more "classic" if colorized display just made sense to me.
The size issues are obviously a consideration with the LCD version on things liek Doctor Who, Addams Family, etc... But I leave that one up to you and what you are comfortable with doing to your machine. I always try to err on the side of completely and (reasonably) simple rollbacks if/when the need arises.
I've had the ColorDMD LED unit in my Doctor Who for a couple of years now and have never questioned the choice.
YMMV! (obviously)
I agree with you on this.
Doctor Who is sort of a retro, rough and tumble, kinda game.
Smoothing the display may not fit the feel of it.
I put the LCD version on my ToM and and am using the smooth font. It matches the game IMHO...
I heavily swayed towards the LED for this title.
Its bright. I has dots. It looks great. Its way easier to install.
Pretty much sold on it.
Now...What Alt translite to get.
Again Im swayed towards the one Rdoyle used. It looks really perfect and totally modernizes the game
Pretty inexpensive on Ebay right now.