Quoted from kbliznick:For me it comes down to this;
LED version is brighter, a few bucks cheaper and easier to install.
LCD allows more animation variations with the connected/interlaced dots.
Not sure which one has more power draw on the 12V and 5V circuits, but I imagine it's the LED.
LED is usually preferable unless the game has great cartoon like animations, like AC/DC, Stern Star Trek and Doctor Who. So it's a toss up in this case
Having put both into my doctor who, I prefer the LED hands down.