Quoted from cottonm4:
Stupid argument? Interesting.
Murder is not accepted in any society I have studied. Murder carries a punitive penalty in the countries I am familiar with. Either life in prison and the death penalty.
Then you haven´t studied many cultures. There are cultures today, totally ok with stoning people for adultry. Killing your offspring for falling in love with the wrong boy.
There are also countries today, that has no problem with deathpenalty for minor drug infractions.
you dont have to go back more then a fifty years or so and there were cultures ok with cannibalism.
What is ok, is a matter of cultural acceptance, and also what it evolves to. Unfortunately currently there is a slid in western culture that is more and more ok with things that are obviously harmful to society. Now it is cannabis, what comes next and where does that path end?
Quoted from cottonm4:
So, you want to forbid something. Doesn't matter what it is that you want to forbid. How are you going to control it. How are you going to police it. You can forbid something all you want but without some sort of punitive measure attached no one will pay attention to what you and what you just banned.
A trouble to enforce a law isn´t an arguement against it. How easy is it to enforce laws of adultry? Wife beating?
So we should be ok with beating the wife, or the kid? There are lots of cultures that are ok with it, and it´s a well hidden crime and really difficult to enforce?
Much more so then smoking.
Quoted from cottonm4:
My question remains.
Without a law there is nothing to enforce. What law are you going to put on the books?
Beyond jumping up and down, pulling your hair out, and waving your hands in the air, how would you control the ban on smoking and vaping?
I dont really see where you are going with this. Generally laws are made to inflict punishment on thoose hurting the society, or the people within.
This can sometimes be tricky, since there are lots of activities that are a mix of hurtful and benefit.
you may argue that driving a car for fun is hurtful to society and the environment, but it´s fun and instills a feeling of freedom for the person doing it.
That is for most a fairly easy one.
How about alcohol? Hurtful for sure, but many people enjoy aspects of it, and it´s an important part in cleaning, somewhat in cooking etc etc.
In my own view alcohol is hanging on the ropes.
Smoking?
My opinion is that there are very little redeeming qualities for smoking. It´s a niquitine fix for nervous people. It has zero real qualities going for it, and loads and loads against it.