I reconnected the playfield and did a bit more cleaning/adjusting of switches. The game over light goes off and it acts like it's starting a game, the ball ejects and the flippers work but the score motor continues to run constantly and the eject/outhole coil keeps pulsing like the ball is still in there. The outhole and trough switches are clean and work. The flipper post (that pops up in between them) also keeps pulsing down over and over.
I can score points too if I touch the switches on the playfield although any switch that activates a coil (like the post down/doodlebug switch/saucer) make the score reel freak out for a second and then completely resets itself back to all zeros).
I can't help but feel like all this is related somehow but I'm trying to take it one step at a time.