Quoted from goingincirclez:Thanks for the feedback everyone. I was leaning toward leaving them out, but wasn't sure if that was going a step too far. And you're right, I guess most new games don't have the bars either, does anyone know when that happened? As for the pins, I agree that as long as the flippers are "meant" to be set straight with the feed lanes, they aren't necessary. But if the designer's intent is a lower/drooped alignment I can see where they would be handy. Diner, I think, should be straight.
~~~~~~~
On another topic, I'll share a pic from my restore thread with some ideas for what they may be worth. I got the new cup from mike200mph and it looks great! And while applying the stickers my daughter noticed and confirmed my own thoughts, which is that the stripe as usually seen (including our own original) is almost always upside down. Because on the handle, the red stripe is on top... so that's how she put the stripe on the cup, to match. I think it looks better this way but as admitted above, I have a bit of OCD about silly stuff.
The other mod I did was to the cup bracket: I used a Dremel cut-off wheel and chopped/rounded the corners to match the bottom of the cup. No more unsightly large pointy metal blocking the upper lanes. The spoon plate is still just as rigid, so no worries there: the original square bracket shape was for ease of manufacture; the reduction of supporting surface in that area is not enough to impair function.
[quoted image]
I think there are two ways to approach restorations... make it look and play absolutely identical to the way it came from the factory... OR... make it look and play fantastically, just like it came from the factory, except make improvements or corrections to mistakes made in the design or manufacturing. Either is fine in my opinion, but you can't have both. And for those OCD reasons you've already mentioned.
That cup sticker for example I would put on in the same orientation as it came from the factory. That's just me. It's not an impediment to play like it could be for example if having it the other way around blocked your view of something behind it.
We have new, replacement and improved technology cup spin switches now. Others installing these have commented that they want the switches to register every spin of the ball around the cup and not just every other rotation, like the original switches and code do for us. If the game was meant to take every other rotation into account for scoring, that's how I'd rather see my game play.
Some of the inside painting of the game cabinets was pretty sloppy looking. Funhouse for example has the nice, bright blue paint, and yet it is all over the map inside the cabinet and looks awful. Authentic, but awful. If I was going to repaint a cabinet, I would do everything consistent on all surfaces, but that might not match the purists view.
There are just as many examples in old car restorations. Guys that are adamant about originality will actually reglue brand new weather striping inside the hood to look sloppy and careless because that's how the factory did it. That makes no sense to me, but there you go. Different strokes for different folks.
Personally, I focus more on making sure the game plays as perfect as I can get it to. So not having a lot of toys and other mods blocking your view is important to me. That's boring to some, but ok, to each his own.