Its all opinion so take this for what its worth.
I had Drac, DH, TFTC and a bunch of other games so we have some similar taste.
I enjoyed DemoMan and miss it. I played tons of shadow in league and didn't like it.
Judge Dredd has a funky layout and while I love the theme, it is fun for a while but overall doesn't hold my interest.
CFTBL is lame in my opinion, not fun at all. Its about as fun as Hook, maybe you like that game, maybe not.
DemoMan has fun ramps, some fun multiballs, a cool elevator/claw, some nice animations. I'm voting foe DemoMan
Quoted from Robertstone0407:Really torn on my next game. I got a bram stoners Dracula, tales of Arabian nights, tales from the crypt, dirty harry and congo l. Most of my play is casual, most of my guests are non pin heads. I've played them all and I'm leaning to shadow. I'm a big color dnd guy. Price wise is have to save for a cftbl but it's on my list