Quoted from PinballTilt:Don't forget the super game feature on JD. That alone earns my vote based on the new player criteria. It's a win win for me regardless though, as I know the op and it's one more game I don't have to buy
I'd agree. Out of all of these if you want to appeal to the widest amount of people it is JD or DM. However, the Super Game on JD wins out. It's a great way for kids and novice players to get to experience a great multiball. I sold my JD and my wife has said she wouldn't mind seeing another one come in again. Her and my son really liked it.
Shadow is way to hard and frustrating for most casual people. However, Shadow is the only one of the three I currently have in my collection and I'm enjoying it, but not even the rest of the family enjoys it much. Wife has told me on more than one occasion to sell it when I'm bored and buy something else.