This has been asked before but I’m curious what the “final” verdict is now that these are both matured and many of you have had a chance to own them both.

As an aside, which do you think would be the best compliment to my collection? I only have room for 3 games and Star Wars and GNR SE are definitely keepers for me. I’m looking for something that offers a nice balance between those two games and has good lastabilty.

Thank you all for your feedback.

I’ll give this one bump and then go away

Yea that’s what I’m thinking although prices are so absurd right now that I can probably get a NIB for $300 more than a used one.

What made Maiden more special?

agree on the keeper thing, I guess I meant that I like those games and I hope to keep them for more than 6 months lol

Thanks guys... I’m actually a fan of Maiden music so I love the theme. What attracts me to Deadpool is the art, humor, and mass appeal for friends. Though friends come over to play like 4 times a year lol. This seems pretty unanimous so far, funny since I feel like the last few times I saw this type of thread it was a slight lean towards Deadpool.

Another question, how similar does Maiden feel to JP2 layout wise?