Deadpool Pro is the best bag for the buck. EHOH is great, but currently caught in the FOMO/high price cycle. AIQ is very popular, but I don’t care for it.

If the animations and sound on TMNT bother you, you need to avoid AIQ, as they’re significantly more terrible.

I enjoy TMNT and AIQ tremendously in spite of their (minor) shortcomings, though, so I don’t think we have similar taste.

Deadpool is solid all around but the layout to me is very ho-hum. Fun game to play on location, but not enough legs for the home.

EHOH is ok, but I don’t see where the premium price point is on the playfield.

Deadpool. Always fun and entertaining. Not the most challenging shots.
AIQ shoots like a dream but it's a pinball strategy game. Which gem goes where? Plus the animations and callouts are not great.
Elvira is fun and shoots well. Clips are good and Elvira is funny.

Really depends on the what the themes do for you. My vote was for Deadpool.

Deadpool

EHOH. This pin is freakin amazing! I will never sell mine. Yeah it’s on the upper end of the price range but worth every penny.

Although I am thinking about buying a Dead Pool pro.

Deadpool Premium or Avengers Infinity Quest Premium

Is Elvira still being made?

I agree with you on turtles, it just falls flat for me. Great looking machine, art is spot on. But something about it just makes me loose interest after a couple games and walk away. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the other 3.

I have a DP prem on order, i like it much better than the pro. Would love an EHOH, but not for the going rate. Avengers has great gameplay but is a bit generic with the them integration imo.

Maybe post up a trade a take whichever offer you like best?