Bout 3 years ago when I started turning over my collection, sold everything except PotC.
It's a great pin for kids as well as elders, guess you could say good for all ages
When I got new pins, I always thought since it was so long in my collection it would be first to go, but I keep putting it aside and can't bring myself to sell it.
I might go a solid month without ever turning it on, but every time I get back to it its fun. It's not complex but I'll take a lot is shots to get to the end.
It's well built, one of those pins you lift the PF and see they didn't cut too many corners and my pin has been almost flawless so far as mechanical breakdowns. Just the auto plunger has broken once.
It's not the most fun or the most intense or the deepest but it's good across most ratings. Good rules, good toys, good theme, good shots, good art, good call outs and music and sound effects.
It's biggest demerit is how long it plays you need to make a lot of shots seemingly just to get to the wizard mode. Guess that's true of most games but PotC is very simple which is good for beginners but myself I'd rather get to the end modes sooner. Maybe soon I will make it to 4 winds and beyond.