You have to have good comments and bad. It's not really a fair evaluation if the negative comments were taken away. Some people base their next pin off what others think of it (I don't know why someone would do this but it happens), so you want both sides of the fence. But you don't need to own a game to know if it sucks or not. If you play it at shows, or route, why would you buy it if it's terrible? I've played enough shit tales in my day, to know i'm never buying one.