If you disregard hindsight then staking makes sense as a “I don’t know what I really want to do, so I’ll HODL and ride it out” strategy. You’re adding more to your pot that you’ve already decided is committed.
The problem with the argument against staking and just playing the market instead is that it assumes that past returns are an indicator of future returns, which is like the first thing you’re told not to follow in traditional investments.
If we could all predict to a certainty the dips, even the small ones, then you’d make a fortune just buying and selling at the right time. As we don’t have the power - staking, earning interest, is essentially a sure fire thing in uncertain times.
I just wish staking was available on Coinbase. All my crypto stuff is on there, I’m not on any other websites, so can’t do anything with my ETH, ADA, etc (I thought staking ETH was available on Coinbase, but I don’t see any option to do it).