Well, I can see the quality issues in the photos. No contest.
I know this seller well. I will say beyond any shadow of doubt that he is an honest person, and probably made the “favor” comment due to the lack of availability. The comment that it was/wasn’t like that was based in honesty.... possibly in error, but honestly.
I also know enough about him to say he would gladly pay you back to get the playfield back (with shipping). You can call us out if you don’t get your money back. We stand behind that.
Now, I understand your position. You have looked high and low for a good one, and thought you found it.. and paid up. I get that for sure. Now, this disappointing discovery has left you with a decision to return and continue to look for another needle in the hay stack, or keep and fix. That sucks.
Sounds like the ink issues are through the run. I won’t defend, not dis CPR, as I too have spent 30 yrs screen printing. It’s very process is riddled with potential issues (even forgetting the poor/less than perfect wood substrate the the pinball world standardized on... and it’s inherent variations) but screens (many ways for those to be screwed up) and films and squeegees and flood bars and ink ... and yes, press operators all pose potential derailing of the project. Then invest in the cnc Cutting, inserts and more to only have on press issues with dripping ink, poor flood coats and more ....RUINING expensive, cut and insert installed and sealed wood. Those boards are of course the ones you didn’t already loose due to warpage before you ever got to the Printing press. These playfields are nothing short of “poster child” projects most screen shops look at and say “ohh hell no”. Trust me.
Anyway it looks like you have CPR originated QC issues, and some post press issues that are identical to what we have all seen over and over. I was just at Expo examining myself these issue on brand new games..... it’s wood folks!
Pirate’s Life is as honest as they come. If he goofed/didn’t inspect, it’s a mistake.
His remarks for it not being bad when he sent, I’m sure are a result of his surprise To see the photos... he just maybe goofed.
Trust me when I say he does not need to try to pawn off a bad playfield for $1,000.
If he says he will give it back... he will.
It’s regrettable you could not work it out between you both without the public shaming. He has given away more money than most common folk through philanthropy... not a person that frankly needs a 1,000.
As for the CPR negative comments... all I can say is screen printing this many colors on wood to the perfection collectors demand is nothing short of a bitch. Should they ship some of what they have? Not mine to judge.
See, I went this far without even mentioning a Hardtop would never do this after manufacturing.
Welp, I hope it works out. Good luck