Let me know if I've missed any. I'll edit the list as errors are found and new ones come out. Note that I used the name of the most recent movie whose content is in the pin; a few pins cover more than one. Also note that I didn't split out Pro/Prem/LE models or EM/SS. I'll try to keep up with all the replies.
1978 Gottlieb Sinbad
1978 Gottlieb Close Encounters of the Third Kind
1979 Stern Meteor
1980 Gottlieb James Bond 007 (The Spy Who Loved Me)
1980 Hankin The Empire Strikes Back
1981 Bally Embryo(n)
1981 Bally Flash Gordon
1982 Gottlieb Rocky
1983 Gottlieb Krull
1987 Sonic Star Wars
1990 Data East King Kong
1990 Data East Robocop
1990 Data East Phantom of the Opera
1990 Data East Back to the Future
1991 Data East Batman
1991 Williams Terminator 2: Judgment Day
1992 Data East Hook
1992 Midway The Addams Family
1992 Bally Creature From the Black Lagoon
1992 Data East Lethal Weapon 3
1992 Data East Star Wars
1993 Williams Bram Stoker's Dracula
1993 Data East Jurassic Park
1993 Williams Indiana Jones (1-3)
1993 Data East Last Action Hero
1994 Data East The Who's Tommy Pinball Wizard
1994 Williams Demolition Man
1994 Williams The Flintstones
1994 Data East Maverick the Movie
1994 Premier Freddy a Nightmare on Elmstreet
1994 Midway The Shadow
1995 Sega Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
1995 Williams Dirty Harry
1995 Premier Stargate
1995 Sega Batman Forever
1995 Williams Johnny Mnemonic
1995 Sega Apollo 13
1995 Premier Waterworld
1995 Williams Congo
1996 Sega Goldeneye
1996 Premier Barb Wire
1996 Sega Twister
1996 Sega Independence Day
1996 Sega Space Jam
1997 Sega Star Wars Trilogy
1997 Sega The Lost World Jurassic Park
1997 Sega The X Files
1997 Sega Starship Troopers
1998 Sega Lost In Space
1998 Sega Godzilla
1999 Williams Star Wars: Episode 1
2001 Stern Austin Powers
2003 Stern Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
2003 Stern The Lord of the Rings
2006 Stern Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Man's Chest
2007 Stern Spider-Man
2007 Zizzle Pirates of the Caribbean At World's End
2008 Stern Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
2008 Stern Batman: The Dark Knight
2010 Stern Iron Man 2
2010 Stern Avatar
2011 Stern Tron Legacy
2011 Stern Transformers: Dark of the Moon
2012 Stern The Avengers
2013 Stern Star Trek Into Darkness
2013 Jersey Jack Wizard of Oz
2015 Jersey Jack The Hobbit
Disqualified:
1975 Bally Captain Fantastic (inspired by Tommy)
1975 Bally Wizard! (inspired by Tommy)
1981 Bally Embryo(n)
1993 Williams STTNG