Ended up being the EOS switch, so I ordered a flipper rebuild kit. Replacing the EOS switches and cabinet flipper switches. Seems I have a new problem now. The flippers are too strong. Despite the fact that I didn't swap out solenoids, a shot up the center Comet ramp sees the ball jumping out near the top almost every time. Tried adjusting the playfield angle to make it more severe but this doesn't seem to remedy the issue. Anybody have any suggestions on what caused this? Is better contact between the new EOS switches providing more power to the coil? I'm starting to think I'm going to need to drop down the coils to a slightly lower power.
Any suggestions would be appreciated.