I have had mine for a few years now. Like others have said, the heart and hand were very deteriorated. These are latex and have a limited lifespan. I managed to find very good replacements from a prop shop. I was even able to mount the heart over the original assembly and make it pump better than the original.
The game is a lot of fun, very different. The audio is exceptionally good with lots of humor and catchy/spooky music. Every time I have a pin party there's always a few new people that comment on how they had never even heard of the game before, but now they love it. Having said that, while the gameplay is good, the depth is lacking. It could get repetative in a small collection. I think this game averaged around $1300 when I started looking. I bought mine for $1000 with the flippers not working. Very few examples come up for sale, but I think the price has climbed a little. Some nice ones have broken the 2k mark.