(Topic ID: 178110)

Change.org Petition: Gary Stern Replace Defective Playfields

By kpg

7 years ago


Topic Heartbeat

Topic Stats

  • 1,257 posts
  • 193 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 7 years ago by Schabs81
  • Topic is favorited by 27 Pinsiders

You

Linked Games

Topic Gallery

View topic image gallery

DSC_3257 (resized).JPG
DSC_3259 (resized).JPG
IMG_20170318_162208 (resized).jpg
IMG_1552 (resized).JPG
IMG_1550 (resized).JPG
IMG_1555 (resized).JPG
IMG_1547.JPG
IMG_1541.JPG
IMG_1542.JPG
IMG_1528.JPG
IMG_2441 (resized).JPG
IMG_1540.JPG
IMG_1538.JPG
honda_accord_99-03 (resized).jpg
ec0f66aced98c3183be5458f366883201f31ba47 (resized).jpg
14868616957031880555332 (resized).jpg

Topic index (key posts)

3 key posts have been marked in this topic (Show topic index)

There are 1,251 posts in this topic. You are on page 11 of 26.
#501 7 years ago
Quoted from joey__p__1966:

For what it's worth,
I have worked for a chemical company for 30 years , making automotive and industrial high performance clearcoats. I am not a chemist, just represent in a technical capacity this company. I am going to make a guess as to what is going on behind the scenes, it would explain the delay in responding. It wouldn't surprise me if a paint company is trying to figure out the clearcoat issues and meet the quality demands and production demands on dry times and hardness. The newest technology is UV dried clears, and they are more brittle than yesterdays acrylic urethane clears . Brittle is bad on a wood sheet that gets beat up by a steel ball. The UV dries super fast, like 5 minutes total dry, no heat to damage the wood or inserts, very attractive to production lines. The Urethane clear is either air dried or heat cured in about 20 minutes, and I'm sure it's low baked ~120F, due to it being wood with plastic glued in inserts. I would not be surprised if some changes in technology is being worked out right now, and trying to figure out a way to meet production demands and provide a suitable clearcoat. I figure Stern ( actually the paint company) is testing different formulas looking for a solution. Just my thoughts, don't have a dog in this fight, just sharing some insight from my perspective. I may be way off and no where close to what the process is, but I am making this guess.
BTW: the white edge on the insert is most likely delamination. It's where the clear has come loose from the substrate and is no longer bonded. The swelling, expanding and retraction of the wood at the insert may be the culprit, and the clear isn't flexible enough to make this minor movement without coming loose. I'm sure they will figure it out, and hopefully soon, as I would like to continue to buy new Stern pins, as they make some really cool stuff these days.
Please don't bash me for my ideas, as I said, it's just a guess from someone in the clearcoat business. But it may help some folks understand just a little about clears of yesterday vs the UV clears of today and why it cant be fixed overnight.
JP

Nailed It !

#502 7 years ago
Quoted from Whysnow:

No, i am saying that i don't really care whom jy specifcally is.

Yeah, I read what you said the first time.

Again, facts do not matter to you. Just because you feel that he is a Stern "schill" (sic) doesn't mean that people should call him Jody after the mods have confirmed that he isn't.

#503 7 years ago
Quoted from RobT:

Facts don't matter to you?

Alternative Facts

#504 7 years ago
Quoted from RobT:

doesn't mean that people should call him Jody after the mods have confirmed that he isn't

correct, if mods have confirmed he is not Jody, then people should not call him Jody. It would be cruel to call anyone Jody, that is not him (despite Zombie's man crush on Jody #creepy). Sorry JY64 for calling you Jody before.

Either way, I will say that JY64 seems to love this title and why he continually posts from that angle and stays hidden but continually tries to deflect and scrub all the issues Stern is not having. I will say that JY64 is not Jody, but acts just like him.

#505 7 years ago

How does one prove that they are someone to a moderator?
Tell a friend to paypal some money to pinside while you are logged in? Seems like a system that is easy to circumvent. In fact, you can see that 'JY64 has donated to Pinside (2017-01-13) !'

Now if you question that you will be ejected....

Seems a bit silly to me.

#506 7 years ago
Quoted from FalconPunch:

Now if you question that you will be ejected....
Seems a bit silly to me.

Believe me there are a few on pinside that can, and will say anything they like to anyone without the least hesitation knowing there will be no action being taken to curb their behaviors. I have come to realize and forced to accept this fact if I want to continue to be a part of this forum.

#507 7 years ago
Quoted from RWH:

Believe me there are a few on pinside that can, and will say anything they like to anyone without the least hesitation knowing there will be no action being taken to curb their behaviors. I have come to realize and forced to accept this fact if I want to continue to be a part of this forum.

+ 1.

-14
#508 7 years ago
Quoted from clg:

That is a prototype DI on location. Not a finished product shipping to customers.

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

a7ca3e798f78d0c37c1039506ea84ec1b9b8398c-1 (resized).jpga7ca3e798f78d0c37c1039506ea84ec1b9b8398c-1 (resized).jpg

16
#509 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

again... You are trying to compare a company with a prototype game with numerous and heavy play (been to multiple shows and also on route at a test location for ~3months) vs production Stern games that are shipped to homes and have MAJOR issues. Really?

Do you even read what you write? Should I post some more photos of routed Sterns with fewer plays but more wear? Keep in mind those are production games.

JJP was smart enough to have this test game out for people to play and have the engineering, code, and design team right near by to keep track of and see what things need to be improved prior to production in Q2 of this year. Seems like a great plan!

#510 7 years ago
Quoted from FalconPunch:

How does one prove that they are someone to a moderator?
Tell a friend to paypal some money to pinside while you are logged in? Seems like a system that is easy to circumvent. In fact, you can see that 'JY64 has donated to Pinside (2017-01-13) !'
Now if you question that you will be ejected....
Seems a bit silly to me.

No actually I gave them my phone # and the name of a pinsider that I did a trade with so just like a thread on how much it cost to make a pin you seem to have one more opinion based on BS

#511 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

It's not a production game! I seem to remember some Stern games on test at Gameworks a number of years back that were prototypes without a professional clearcoat and with makeshift plastics. Not uncommon for something that isn't in full production yet.

#512 7 years ago
Quoted from Whysnow:

I will say that JY64 seems to love this title

It is funny you say that I don't like it at all and you have not heard me say that I do

-1
#513 7 years ago
Quoted from MikeS:

It's not a production game! I seem to remember some Stern games on test at Gameworks a number of years back that were prototypes without a professional clearcoat and with makeshift plastics. Not uncommon for something that isn't in full production yet.

Thank you someone not making a excuse but giving reason behind it

#514 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

Thank you someone not making a excuse but giving reason behind it

??? reading comprehension???

Quoted from Whysnow:

prototype game

Quoted from clg:

That is a prototype DI on location. Not a finished product shipping to customers.

#515 7 years ago

Who will join me for the Playfield March on Chicago?

I'm thinking we get a few million people to march on Grant Park, or even the Stern factory, and we can show this administration that we aren't going to stand for this kind of treatment. Who's with me?

#516 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

"Why does product X have an unusually high rate of Issues"? ..."well product Y has abnormal wear on the play field". Yea, typical pathetic response...

#517 7 years ago
Quoted from Whysnow:

post some more photos of routed Sterns

Hear you are Whysnow from lanes and game if you are from the Boston area you know if has seen heavy play

IMG_1186 (resized).jpgIMG_1186 (resized).jpg

#518 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

Hear you are Whysnow from lanes and game if you are from the Boston area you know if has seen heavy play

lol... you do know Lanes and Games does not even exist anymore??? Pretty funny you just tried to post a photo of TWD (not a game with QC issues) and from ??? how long ago as something recent.

That is funny.

#519 7 years ago
Quoted from Whysnow:

lol... you do know Lanes and Games does not even exist anymore??? Pretty funny you just tried to post a photo of TWD (not a game with QC issues) and from ??? how long ago as something recent.
That is funny.

I know it closed a true loss

#520 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

I know it closed a true loss

got pictures of GB before they closed?

#521 7 years ago
Quoted from Whysnow:

got pictures of GB before they closed?

No I just took that pic in my home

#522 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

It is funny you say that I don't like it at all and you have not heard me say that I do

Like I said: facts do not matter to him.

11
#523 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

I love how you keep posting pics of a JJP machine that has a prototype playfield, likely on route just beta testing. Stern has shipped BM66 already with code that's so bare and empty it's laughable. What company these days ships a consumer electronics product that is only about 10% complete?

Since you love posting these pics, tell me, how much money is the customer out who owns this machine?

That's right, $0

Because nobody fookin paid for this game! It's a JJP sample! They are testing the games the right way, Stern just puts out an ad on the internet and doesn't even show gameplay video until people have already started receiving them. YOU, the customer, are the beta tester.

#524 7 years ago

Been awhile since i read this thread, but....

Quoted from ExtremePinball:

I keep reading about the "small percentage". Another poster claims 1-2% of the playfields are affected.
Allow me to introduce a healthy dose of Reality:

I imagine this is directed towards me from the other thread. I like how you twist words around and continue to do so; for the record, i said a small % of playfields (in general, not just ghostbusters) were affected from EXTREME DISINTEGRATING UNPLAYABLE CONDITIONS like KPG's. Just want to keep the facts straight.

Listen extreme pinball; i like you and what you do for the hobby. You have some of the nicest games on route and ive gone to bat for you in other threads stating this. But please stop twisting my words around like you did in the other thread and this one (if this is directed towards me). I feel for you and anyone dealing with these playfield issues i really do. Are your pins inoperable due to ghosting inserts? What has your distributor said about this issue? are you on the list for sterns replacement program? Can you share your pics you sent stern to get on the replacement program?

#525 7 years ago
Quoted from Mike_J:

I hope everything works out for all, but that post sure was uncomfortable.

Yes I agree, ZombiYeti's post certainly was very very weird to say the least. Dont say anything bad about the almighty Zombi though because there are some crazies here on this site that will want to actually fight you if you say anything negative at all about the guy lol. He comes on here basically threatening to quit doing artwork on pinball machines (I guess he thinks pinball will fail without his greatness) and I simply suggested that maybe its time to move onto other things (factory work maybe instead of drawing?) If doing work for the unappreciative pinball crowd is getting to him mentally. I meant nothing by it and wasnt even being an ass to the guy in the least. I will tell anybody, if you are in a job that is causing you alot of stress and affecting your mental health, its time to move on because its not worth it. I quickly learned that a few people on here give this guy like God status or something and will actually threaten you and want to fight you over him. Too funny!

I personally think pinball will survive just fine if he decides to leave us so im not worried at all, I just dont want the guy to have a mental breakdown or develop a drinking problem because of us pinball jerks. Being an Artist is tough, I don't know how he does it.

#526 7 years ago
Quoted from kpg:

I love how you keep posting pics of a JJP machine that has a prototype playfield, likely on route just beta testing. Stern has shipped BM66 already with code that's so bare and empty it's laughable. What company these days ships a consumer electronics product that is only about 10% complete?
Since you love posting these pics, tell me, how much money is the customer out who owns this machine?
That's right, $0
Because nobody fookin paid for this game! It's a JJP sample! They are testing the games the right way, Stern just puts out an ad on the internet and doesn't even show gameplay video until people have already started receiving them. YOU, the customer, are the beta tester.

I think it is funny you bring up payment on JJP games as people are still waiting on TH

#527 7 years ago

Met pro in home use after 100 or so plays...... that is just 2 examples ,there are plenty more out there . I saw many production met with this issue. Also look at sm and the wear it gets in some cases. This type of magnet in the right conditions without mylar around it will get wear . A simple piece of mylar on the dialed in wld have stopped that wear most likely....that particular magnet gets a ton of action and is very active and is y jjp will learn from this and ajusted accordingly. They sld probably make it a under playfield magnet like the other 4? It all depends what they wanna do with it in gameplay.27071211e405f69ca3eb9fc98cfa90517a681a5c.jpeg.jpg27071211e405f69ca3eb9fc98cfa90517a681a5c.jpeg.jpg3aae24a3a492c4a1596e5c57a64084d1a543b766.jpg3aae24a3a492c4a1596e5c57a64084d1a543b766.jpg

#528 7 years ago
Quoted from Who-Dey:

I quickly learned that a few people on here give this guy like God status or something and will actually threaten you and want to fight you over him. Too funny!

Yeah, those folks should be institutionalized.

#529 7 years ago
Quoted from bigd1979:

Met pro in home use after 100 or so plays...... that is just 2 examples ,there are plenty more out there . I saw many production met with this issue. Also look at sm and the wear it gets in some cases. This type of magnet in the right conditions without mylar around it will get wear . A simple piece of mylar on the dialed in wld have stopped that wear most likely....that particular magnet gets a ton of action and is very active and is y jjp will learn from this and ajusted accordingly. They sld probably make it a under playfield magnet like the other 4? It all depends what they wanna do with it in gameplay.

Is this your machine? When was it produced? Thanks!

#530 7 years ago
Quoted from JY64:

You can make all the excuses you like but a heavy routed game after one year should have no play field wear. This pic by the Pinside thread time line is after six weeks. The playfield wear on the bat is not acceptable either dimples yes playfield wear no

Test game. I wish Stern did the same thing...maybe then they would have caught all of these playfield issues and dozens of owners wouldn't be stuck with faulty playfields. Nah, ship em anyway.

#531 7 years ago
Quoted from bigd1979:

Met pro in home use after 100 or so plays......

Wow.... just WOW!!!!

15
#532 7 years ago
Quoted from bigd1979:

Met pro in home use after 100 or so plays...... that is just 2 examples ,there are plenty more out there . I saw many production met with this issue. Also look at sm and the wear it gets in some cases. This type of magnet in the right conditions without mylar around it will get wear . A simple piece of mylar on the dialed in wld have stopped that wear most likely....that particular magnet gets a ton of action and is very active and is y jjp will learn from this and ajusted accordingly. They sld probably make it a under playfield magnet like the other 4? It all depends what they wanna do with it in gameplay.

But does it still "Play Fine" ? YES- so who cares! Buy an extra playfield, Stern is going to sell more pins than ever in 2017! -Iceman

Jody Dankburg is handsome and I want to spoon him -ZombiYeti

19
#533 7 years ago
Quoted from Eskaybee:

Been awhile since i read this thread, but....

I imagine this is directed towards me from the other thread. I like how you twist words around and continue to do so; for the record, i said a small % of playfields (in general, not just ghostbusters) were affected from EXTREME DISINTEGRATING UNPLAYABLE CONDITIONS like KPG's. Just want to keep the facts straight.
Listen extreme pinball; i like you and what you do for the hobby. You have some of the nicest games on route and ive gone to bat for you in other threads stating this. But please stop twisting my words around like you did in the other thread and this one (if this is directed towards me). I feel for you and anyone dealing with these playfield issues i really do. Are your pins inoperable due to ghosting inserts? What has your distributor said about this issue? are you on the list for sterns replacement program? Can you share your pics you sent stern to get on the replacement program?

It was most certainly not directed at you. It is directed at all of the repeated (from multiple sources) bullshit speculation that "only a small percentage" of playfields are affected. Based on what?!?! Based on the one playfield somebody saw that looked fine when they unboxed it????

Of the 3 playfields I have personally viewed, all 3 have ghosting, and crater size divots. Two of them are mine and appeared fine NIB..... that didn't last. The third is at the PHoF. Another poster, either in this thread or another, has stated that 4 of the 4 playfields the poster saw where ghosted. 100% failure rate is not a small percentage to me.

Understand that I have personally unboxed, tested, prepped and played no less than 2 dozen brand new Stern games in the last 2.5 years. Until GB, I had never seen craters this large, nor have I seen a single ghosted insert.

Inoperable? No. Unacceptable? You bet it is. Unfortunately I HAD faith in this company to increase their QC after the previous debacles they put out, not to just totally give up on QC. It is clear, going back to at least TWD, that Stern does not even bother to test their own finished product, or, they KNOW the games have issues, but ships them anyway and roll the dice. When EVERY shot up Bicycle Girls ramp on an TWDLE results in a launched air ball, and then months later they put out a "fix", it supports what I've just stated above. When a complete lack of ability to make the orbit on a GoTLE, which is then fixed with a code change so the orbit isn't necessary, it supports what I've just stated above. Do I really need to bring up the fact that the code is buggy and unfinished on EVERY game they produce?!?!?!

I built my entire business based on quality, not quantity. Stern is no longer producing quality, they've opted for quantity. They can keep their quantity. If I should decide to buy a BM66 or an Aerosmith.... or any other future title, it will be in the secondary market.... after the first sucker dealt with all of the flaws, defects, issues, and lack of code.

#534 7 years ago
Quoted from bigd1979:

Met pro in home use after 100 or so plays...... that is just 2 examples ,there are plenty more out there . I saw many production met with this issue. Also look at sm and the wear it gets in some cases. This type of magnet in the right conditions without mylar around it will get wear . A simple piece of mylar on the dialed in wld have stopped that wear most likely....that particular magnet gets a ton of action and is very active and is y jjp will learn from this and ajusted accordingly. They sld probably make it a under playfield magnet like the other 4? It all depends what they wanna do with it in gameplay.

Wow, sorry you have to deal with that. Hope Stern sends you a new fully populated playfield.

Does your Met have a recent build date or was it affected from the small batch of games with playfield issues from a couple years ago?

#535 7 years ago
Quoted from ExtremePinball:

It is directed at all of the repeated (from multiple sources) bullshit speculation that "only a small percentage" of playfields are affected. Based on what?!?!

Based on the available evidence. 656 Ghostbusters Premium/LE owners, 258 Ghostbusters Pro owners
That's 914 units. How many confirmed reports of acceptance into the playfield replacement program? Ten? Twenty? Fifty? If it's twenty that's only 2%. What would it take to get from 2% to a large percentage of playfields?
Would you agree that 20% is a large percentage of playfields? I don't think that number have been reported publicly but I agree it's not impossible, it's just not likely. We need better data to draw more accurate conclusions.

Quoted from ExtremePinball:

Of the 3 playfields I have personally viewed, all 3 have ghosting, and crater size divots. Two of them are mine and appeared fine NIB..... that didn't last. The third is at the PHoF. Another poster, either in this thread or another, has stated that 4 of the 4 playfields the poster saw where ghosted. 100% failure rate is not a small percentage to me.

Your personal experience doesn't match the reported experience of Ghostbusters owners as a whole.

#536 7 years ago
Quoted from YeOldPinPlayer:

Your personal experience doesn't match the reported experience of Ghostbusters owners as a whole.

There are 10 GB pro on route in Wi. I have seens and played 7 of them. ALL 7 have insert ghosting, clear coat chipping, and issues.

I have played 3 other GB on route in my travels the past year. ALL 3 of those also have issues. I am yet to see a single GB on route without atleast 1 insert ghosting.

#537 7 years ago
Quoted from ExtremePinball:

It was most certainly not directed at you. It is directed at all of the repeated (from multiple sources) bullshit speculation that "only a small percentage" of playfields are affected. Based on what?!?! Based on the one playfield somebody saw that looked fine when they unboxed it????
Of the 3 playfields I have personally viewed, all 3 have ghosting, and crater size divots. Two of them are mine and appeared fine NIB..... that didn't last. The third is at the PHoF. Another poster, either in this thread or another, has stated that 4 of the 4 playfields the poster saw where ghosted. 100% failure rate is not a small percentage to me.
Understand that I have personally unboxed, tested, prepped and played no less than 2 dozen brand new Stern games in the last 2.5 years. Until GB, I had never seen craters this large, nor have I seen a single ghosted insert.
Inoperable? No. Unacceptable? You bet it is. Unfortunately I HAD faith in this company to increase their QC after the previous debacles they put out, not to just totally give up on QC. It is clear, going back to at least TWD, that Stern does not even bother to test their own finished product, or, they KNOW the games have issues, but ships them anyway and roll the dice. When EVERY shot up Bicycle Girls ramp on an TWDLE results in a launched air ball, and then months later they put out a "fix", it supports what I've just stated above. When a complete lack of ability to make the orbit on a GoTLE, which is then fixed with a code change so the orbit isn't necessary, it supports what I've just stated above. Do I really need to bring up the fact that the code is buggy and unfinished on EVERY game they produce?!?!?!
I built my entire business based on quality, not quantity. Stern is no longer producing quality, they've opted for quantity. They can keep their quantity. If I should decide to buy a BM66 or an Aerosmith.... or any other future title, it will be in the secondary market.... after the first sucker dealt with all of the flaws, defects, issues, and lack of code.

Right on, thanks for clearing that up.

And i'm not an operator but have unboxed approximately 15 NIB Sterns since entering the hobby 10 years ago and haven't seen playfield issues like we are seeing. Like you said earlier in this thread, and i have in other threads, whatever stern was doing a year or 2 ago, go back to that method - problem solved! But, being in the hobby for so long i have seen a difference between buying 1st production NIB games vs late production NIB games whether it was last year, or 5 years ago. I've finally got sick and tired of being the guinea pig and stopped buying in on these early model production games. It sucks for operators more than home buyers though because it's their business to make money and keep the business rolling. At least for home collectors we can have the luxury of waiting and pick n' choose how we so desire.

So i feel for you bro, i just hope you keep putting out quality pins at your locations with what you have to work with and as a customer, and hobby enthusiast, i recommend you stay clear of LE/Prem games for route as from what ive heard and read, they are much more difficult to operate. And your location Pro machines are as nice or sometimes nicer than an LE (i.e. your TWD & MET Pro's). LE features for the most part are added gimmicks, and Stern doesnt typically program these extra features with much attention like JJP does to their machines.

#538 7 years ago
Quoted from kpg:

But does it still "Play Fine" ? YES- so who cares! Buy an extra playfield, Stern is going to sell more pins than ever in 2017! -Iceman
Jody Dankburg is handsome and I want to spoon him -ZombiYeti

Thumbs up again on the Iceman quote.

Not sure where you are going with the Yeti thing

Xtreme pinball says his RRWoz play field is destroyed after 10k plays while the IRon Man VE and Avatar are still looking good after 17k plays.

#539 7 years ago
Quoted from iceman44:

Thumbs up again on the Iceman quote.
Not sure where you are going with the Yeti thing
Xtreme pinball says his RRWoz play field is destroyed after 10k plays while the IRon Man VE and Avatar are still looking good after 17k plays.

What he's saying is, Yeti's post was very weird and he has a very odd sense of humor. When I read it I thought it was very .....I'll be nice and just say different and odd. It also kinda reminded me of when an actor or musician speaks out against a politician or something. I kinda just felt like saying....dude just draw art on my pinball machine and let Stern deal with the shitty quality that they themselves have created. Anyway enough of that. Iron man and Avatar playfields were better quality than todays Stern playfields also, so you really cant use them for examples.

Oh yeah...ang KPG loves you!

#540 7 years ago
Quoted from Eskaybee:

At least for home collectors we can have the luxury of waiting and pick n' choose how we so desire.

Not if we want LEs. Those that pay the most for their games get to be the guinea pigs during the early builds. Not sure how to fix that, but it doesn't make sense.

#541 7 years ago
Quoted from jfh:

Not if we want LEs. Those that pay the most for their games get to be the guinea pigs during the early builds. Not sure how to fix that, but it doesn't make sense.

You're paying for the right to get it early before the public does. Congrats!

#542 7 years ago
Quoted from TheLaw:

You're paying for the right to get it early before the public does. Congrats!

I'm paying for Stern to get it right.

#543 7 years ago
Quoted from jfh:

I'm paying for Stern to get it right.

Yup...and why people keep doing it is beyond me. Hope Gary's John Hancock down LE buyers throats is worth it.

#544 7 years ago
Quoted from jfh:

Not if we want LEs. Those that pay the most for their games get to be the guinea pigs during the early builds. Not sure how to fix that, but it doesn't make sense.

Easy solution start a thread of endless bitching asking for the LE games to ship last so all issues are ironed out

#545 7 years ago
Quoted from Eskaybee:

i have seen a difference between buying 1st production NIB games vs late production NIB games whether it was last year, or 5 years ago. I've finally got sick and tired of being the guinea pig and stopped buying in on these early model production games. It sucks for operators more than home buyers though because it's their business to make money and keep the business rolling. At least for home collectors we can have the luxury of waiting and pick n' choose how we so desire.

Well I'm in a similar, but worse, situation as I'm now disappointed as both an operator, and a collector. I was buying at least 1 pro and 1 LE of every title. Many titles even more. That ended. Not even JJP. Way too many problems. I may try one of the newer companies, but in a commercial/tourist environment, I need Licensed & Branded titles to earn a living. MMR & DI simply won't earn for me.

To make it even worse, I'm the technician in my arcade business, so I really don't want my only hobby to be "just like work", so to speak. So, as an operator, I'm buying a lot more video arcade games this year, and as a collector, I've already taken up a new hobby.

With all that said, I'm not totally giving up on pinball. I'm just going to limit all of my purchases to the local secondary market where I can personally inspect the condition of every game. Buyer beware.

#546 7 years ago
Quoted from ExtremePinball:

MMR & DI simply won't earn for me.

Don't feel bad, back in the day MM never earned for me, AND balls used to get stuck on the castle turrets and dragon wings.

15
#547 7 years ago

Hi all,

I have remained silent in this thread since it has started and read all the comments. I myself own a GB Premium with playfield issues. I have not signed the petition at this point and I am not sure doing so will help my case at all. Here is the timeline of what has transpired so far.

12/13/16 - My initial e-mail to my distributor.

I have compiled some pictures of some ghosting inserts and cracked clear coat on my machine. I noticed cracks in the clear coat under the apron on October 18th. I first noticed the small amount of ghosting on the Super Jackpot insert on November 1st. Since it was not very much I decided to let it ride for a while to see if it was going to get worse or if other inserts would appear to have this issue. When I looked over the machine last night (12-13-16) to install the Ecto Goggle protector you mailed me I noticed the Proton Pack insert also has a small amount of ghosting, the shooter lane clear coat is cracked, and the ball drain/ball trough hole has begun to crack/chip. Unfortunately for me it seems as though my playfield is one of the many that are having issues. Since I have first noticed it to now I have seen the clear coat cracking and ghosting inserts grow in size.

I also noticed on the insert "Okay, who brought the dog" there somehow is light coming through the side of the insert. I don't really know if that is "Ghosting" or if somehow it has become separated/ raised? I have not noticed this on any other inserts.

Some of the pictures it is really obvious, others its hard to tell like the shooter lane and ball trough. If you need better pictures of those areas please let me know and I will grab my girlfriends high resolution camera. The pictures I have attached were all taken with my phone.

The game itself including the code update from original code version to V1.10 has under 200 plays.

12/13/16 - Distributor forwarded my e mail and CC me to Patrick Powers at Stern.

01/23/17 - Response to my case from Patrick Powers

At this time, the amount of insert ghosting and hard coat chipping doesn’t warrant a replacement playfield. Please ask your customer to continue keeping an eye on the playfield for any changes.

Regards,
Pat

Basically I have been put on a "Wait and lets see what happens with it" program. This is very upsetting to me as I had originally waited to even contact them about it to see if it got worse and it has since I first documented the issue. I like iceman44 said had faith that Stern would take care of my problem. I do understand that my playfield is not as bad as others out there but I personally still feel my case warrants a replacement. Needless to say I am very disappointed in Stern not willing at this time to make things right for me.

I work for my family business in the air conditioning and heating industry and if I have a customer that is not happy with anything I will do whatever I can to make sure that that customer is happy. There have even been a few situations where we have gone to a customers home that purchased new equipment from us and replaced the entire outdoor condenser at no cost to them (outside of our labor warranty) because of all the issues we were having with it. The warranty and technical support departments would not approve the replacement even though it was the right thing to do in those situations. (Those units were lemons and had to have several circuit boards replaced along with compressor problems. In our opinion the customer purchased a NEW product and did not deserve to have a brand new "Frankenstein" unit) I want return business so we can grow, and keep up our reputation as a reliable and trustworthy company. I would have assumed that Stern would have some of the same morals and ethics that I hold in my company.

I know of 6 other Ghostbusters in my immediate area (3 early pros, 2 LE's, 1 premium) that do not have ghosting or clear coat problems.

Where my apron sits there is actually a divot in the playfield where the apron edges sit. You should be able to see it clearly in the attached pictures. The two insert arrows that show ghosting have slightly grown in size since I sent the original e mail. I have not checked under the apron again since the time I originally took pictures in October. I know the trough entrance picture is hard to see the clear chipping but its there.

All in all I am very very disappointed. This was my first ever NIB purchase for HUO. I like this game a lot and I like the titles Stern is releasing and I would love to be able to continue to purchase their products, but if my case is not resolved my faith in Stern will be greatly diminished to the point to where I may never purchase a NIB again and just stick to the pre owned market like another Pinsider mentioned so you can inspect the game. My 2013 Metallica Pro has had 0 issues since I purchased it from another Pinsider. No clear coat problems, no mechanical problems. I wish I could say the same for my GB.

I look at this situation as no different than buying a new car that has no clear coat problems when it leaves the lot and a few weeks later the clear coat is coming off. Don't you think that car company you purchased the vehicle from would make it right for you? I sure hope they would.

I know this is a toy and the car comparison is much different situation but I felt it relates to this situation.

If you have some constructive criticism to offer on my situation I am willing to hear it, but I did not post this to be attacked.

At this point I am truly at a loss as to what I should do. Live with it? Fight it? What would you do?

Have a good day.

Gb Ball Eject 1 (resized).jpgGb Ball Eject 1 (resized).jpg

GB Ball Eject (resized).jpgGB Ball Eject (resized).jpg

GB Insert 2 (resized).jpgGB Insert 2 (resized).jpg

GB Shooer Lane 1 (resized).jpgGB Shooer Lane 1 (resized).jpg

GB Trough 2 (resized).jpgGB Trough 2 (resized).jpg

GB Trough 3 (resized).jpgGB Trough 3 (resized).jpg

GB Under Apron 1 (resized).jpgGB Under Apron 1 (resized).jpg

GB Under Apron (resized).jpgGB Under Apron (resized).jpg

Playfield Date (resized).jpgPlayfield Date (resized).jpg

Playfield Serial Number (resized).jpgPlayfield Serial Number (resized).jpg

Playfield (resized).jpgPlayfield (resized).jpg

GB Insert 3 (resized).jpgGB Insert 3 (resized).jpg

GB Insert (resized).jpgGB Insert (resized).jpg

#548 7 years ago

Damage from the apron isn't that uncommon.. but I can't say I've seen it with the big floating plastic ones stern has been using..

Where you see light coming through the black keyline on inserts.. check if the insert has lifted or if the clear is chipped from above.

#549 7 years ago

Seems the lack of standard criteria and the playfield evaluations are unevenly being administered. Yours looks to have enough issues that a replacement is warranted. You shouldn't have to but .. I'd continue to make a nuisance of yourself to your distributor and Stern.

#550 7 years ago
Quoted from jeffspinballpalace:

Seems the lack of standard criteria and the playfield evaluations are unevenly being administered. Yours looks to have enough issues that a replacement is warranted.

Really?

The biggest flaw was under the apron. The PF isn't perfect, but this is not an example of a PF that I would ever expect to get a new PF replacement for... by a long shot.

Would love to hear Vids opinion on this one.

Promoted items from Pinside Marketplace and Pinside Shops!
9,250
Machine - For Sale
Alpine, CALIFORNIA
$ 99.99
Playfield - Toys/Add-ons
Lighted Pinball Mods
 
$ 69.99
Playfield - Toys/Add-ons
Lighted Pinball Mods
 
$ 30.00
Playfield - Other
YouBentMyWookie
 
32,495
Machine - For Sale
Ontario, CA
From: $ 399.95
Lighting - Led
Pin Stadium Pinball Mods
 
$ 24.95
Playfield - Protection
ULEKstore
 
$ 69.99
Playfield - Toys/Add-ons
Lighted Pinball Mods
 
$ 130.00
Cabinet - Toppers
Docquest Pinball Mods
 
$ 700.00
Hardware
Chrome Candy
 
$ 11.95
Playfield - Toys/Add-ons
ULEKstore
 
$ 4.95
Lighting - Led
Mitchell Lighting
 
$ 63.99
Cabinet - Other
Cento Creations
 
From: $ 218.00
Lighting - Backbox
Lermods
 
$ 19.95
From: $ 30.00
Lighting - Interactive
Pinball Z
 
$ 63.99
Cabinet - Other
Cento Creations
 
From: $ 30.00
Cabinet - Other
Rocket City Pinball
 
From: $ 30.00
From: $ 11.95
Playfield - Toys/Add-ons
ULEKstore
 
From: $ 99.99
Cabinet - Other
Lighted Pinball Mods
 
18,000
7,000 (OBO)
Machine - For Sale
Elgin, OK
$ 20.00
Playfield - Protection
Pinhead mods
 
From: $ 99.99
Cabinet - Other
Lighted Pinball Mods
 
Great pinball charity
Pinball Edu
There are 1,251 posts in this topic. You are on page 11 of 26.

Reply

Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.

Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

Donate to Pinside

Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!


This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/changeorg-petition-gary-stern-replace-defective-playfields/page/11 and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.

Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.