I set out to but JJP POTC... then I played it. It’s expensive, It’s gorgeous...It’s complex... it’s all those things. I just wasn’t feeling a complex game and didn’t want to put out the extra cash for it at the time. So I went MB (SE)...
... and
... I got bored.
MB is great and has a nice solid classic feel. It just didn’t keep me going back for more.
I have since traded the MB.
This question comes up quite a bit nowadays... to be cliche, this is an apples and oranges situation