Im looking at either JJP POTC vs. New MB. I usually got to Allentown pinfest and I think I will just need to play both games at the show and then decide which one is the winner. As for Hobbit, I own Hobbit and WOZ and I love both. My wife is also a huge Lord of the Rings/Hobbit fan and she loves the videos, callouts and game play. Having a pin at home that makes the wife happy is huge! Makes her more amenable to me buying more pins for the gameroom! My niece who is 6 enjoys bashing the pop up Spider. Win overall! It makes the whole family happy.