Ha, if your wife is voicing a preference, I would count your blessings and at least get that pin! So, Ghostbusters..... probably over Monopoly?
For your 2nd game, you have close to enough budget left for the Star Wars pro, and, honestly, as much as I enjoy playing AFM, I get tired of it after too many plays in a row. Yet I get the SAME (maybe more) satisfaction and adrenaline rush from speed and open playfield of Star Wars but I keep on pressing Start until I run out of money. The speed, depth and various approaches to this game scratch a bigger addictive itch for me than does AFM. So, maybe for you too.